Toddler Milk, PediaSure or Sustagen? What a Fussy Eater Actually Needs

Learn | By Nicola Scruby, Nutritionist | 7 min read

The short answer

Most fussy toddlers don't need a special milk drink. From around 12 months, Australian guidelines say plain full cream milk can be introduced as a drink alongside family food (with water as their main drink), and that toddler milks aren't required for healthy children. PediaSure and Nestlé's Kid Essentials are foods for special medical purposes, made for children at nutritional risk and meant to be used under medical supervision, so they're not an everyday fix for a child who is fussy but growing well. For that child, the answer is usually family food, a sensible amount of milk and, if you like, a low-sugar nutrient top-up in the milk they already drink.

When your toddler is living on air and crackers, the tins in the formula aisle start looking very tempting, especially when you're worried. I get it. My eldest barely ate for two weeks after being sick, so I know that worry well.

So here's an honest, side-by-side look at toddler milk, PediaSure and Sustagen: what they are, what's in them, what Australian guidelines say, and what I'd actually do for a fussy eater.

What's the difference?

These products sit in quite different categories, and that matters more than the marketing:

Drink What it is Age on the label
Plain cow's milk Can be introduced as a drink from around 12 months, alongside family food and water From 12 months
Toddler milk (e.g. Aptamil Profutura 3, a2 Platinum Stage 3, Bellamy's Organic Step 3) Described by the makers as a supplement or supplementary food for toddlers whose diet may not be giving them enough 1 to 3 years
PediaSure (Abbott) A food for special medical purposes, for children at nutritional risk. Abbott's label says to use it only under medical supervision. 1 to 10 years
Kid Essentials (Nestlé, sometimes sold as Sustagen Kid Essentials) A food for special medical purposes for children whose appetite is poor because of a medical condition or illness, to be used under a healthcare professional's supervision 1 to 10 years
Sustagen Everyday (Nestlé) A formulated supplementary food made up with milk. Sustagen notes it may not be suitable as a meal replacement for children. From 3 years

Protein and sugar, side by side

Here's how they compare per 100ml, made up as directed. I've used each brand's own figures:

Drink (per 100ml) Protein Total sugars
a2 Full Cream Milk 3.3g 4.7g
Aptamil Profutura 3 toddler milk 2.5g 8.9g
a2 Platinum Stage 3 toddler milk 2.7g 7.4g
Bellamy's Organic Step 3 toddler milk 3.2g 9.2g
PediaSure Vanilla (made with water) 3g 3.73g

Figures read from each brand's Australian website on 28 October 2026. In the milk and toddler milks, the sugars are almost entirely lactose. Products and recipes change, so check the label on the tin you buy.

A couple of things stand out. The toddler milks have roughly one and a half to two times the sugars of plain full cream milk, and no more protein. To be fair to them, toddler milks are fortified with nutrients like iron, which is the makers' main argument for them, but a toddler eating a reasonable range of family food can get those nutrients from their meals. PediaSure is lower in sugars per 100ml (it's mostly hydrolysed corn starch, with some added sucrose), but it's built for a different job entirely. Nestlé's Kid Essentials lists 7.6g of protein and 13.2g of sugars in each 250ml serve.

What Australian guidelines say about toddler milk

The NHMRC's Infant Feeding Guidelines are clear that toddler milks and special supplementary foods for toddlers aren't required for healthy children. The Royal Children's Hospital says the same thing: most toddlers don't need special toddler foods, milks or formulas, and some contain added ingredients kids don't need.

That doesn't make toddler milk dangerous. It just means you're not missing out if you skip it, and for most families it's an expensive way to buy what milk and food already provide.

Why more milk can make fussy eating worse

From 12 months, the Royal Children's Hospital recommends keeping cow's milk under 500ml a day, and Children's Health Queensland suggests up to 500ml (two cups) a day for 1 to 5 year olds. Milk is filling and naturally low in iron, so a toddler who drinks a lot of it often eats less of the iron-rich food they need, and too much is linked with low iron. If your child is drinking a lot more than that, cutting back can make a real difference to their appetite at meals.

A simple swap

Offer milk with or after meals rather than before them. A toddler who isn't already full of milk is far more likely to try what's on their plate.

When PediaSure or Kid Essentials is the right call

These products are designed for kids who genuinely can't get enough from food, and for that job they're the right tool. Talk to your GP if your child:

  • Is losing weight, or dropping across the lines on their growth chart
  • Has a medical condition affecting how they eat, absorb food or grow
  • Has been unwell and eating very little for more than a few days
  • Eats so few foods that whole food groups are missing for weeks at a time

Your GP, paediatrician or a paediatric dietitian can work out whether a complete nutrition drink is needed, how much, and for how long.

What I'd do for a fussy eater who's growing well

This is the most common situation: a healthy, growing, energetic child who eats about six foods. For them, I'd focus on:

  1. Keep serving family food without pressure. Put one safe food on the plate next to whatever everyone else is eating, and let them decide how much they eat. More on this in The Beige Food Phase.
  2. Put protein at breakfast. Eggs, yoghurt, cheese on toast, or a milkshake. It's often the meal they eat best.
  3. Keep milk sensible. With meals, and not so much that it replaces food.
  4. Make the milk they already drink count. A scoop of a low-sugar protein and nutrient powder made for toddlers turns their usual milk into something more useful, without swapping it for a sweeter drink.

You can find out how much protein toddlers need in How Much Protein Does My Toddler Actually Need?, and how kids' powders compare in Kids Protein Powders in Australia, Compared.

Where our Kids Immune Protein fits

When my eldest was sick and barely eating, I asked him what he'd have if he could have anything. The answer was a choccy milkshake. That's where Kids Immune Protein started.

It's not a formula, a toddler milk or a meal replacement. It's a food you add to the milk your child already drinks: 9g of gentle collagen protein a scoop, with zinc, vitamin C, vitamin D, prebiotic fibre and a probiotic, and no added sugar. It's suitable from 12 months. Our toddler-friendly protein milkshake is the easiest place to start.

If your child is losing weight or not growing as they should, please see your GP first. That's a job for the experts, not a milkshake.

Quick answers

Is toddler milk necessary? No. Australia's infant feeding guidelines say toddler milks aren't required for healthy children. From around 12 months, plain full cream cow's milk can be introduced as a drink, alongside family food and water.

Is PediaSure good for fussy eaters? PediaSure is a food for special medical purposes, made for children aged 1 to 10 who are at nutritional risk, and Abbott says to use it under medical supervision. If your fussy eater is losing weight or dropping off their growth curve, see your GP. If they're growing well, they usually don't need it.

What's the difference between PediaSure and Sustagen? PediaSure (Abbott) is a nutritionally complete drink for children 1 to 10 at nutritional risk. Sustagen's current range has nothing made specifically for young children (Sustagen Everyday is labelled from 3 years). Nestlé's complete drink for children 1 to 10 is called Kid Essentials (some shops still list it as Sustagen Kid Essentials), and it's also a food for special medical purposes.

How much milk should a toddler drink a day? From 12 months, aim for no more than about 500ml (two cups) of cow's milk a day. More than that can fill them up, push out iron-rich food and is linked with low iron in toddlers.

Can I add a protein powder to my toddler's milk? Yes, as long as it's made for young children, at a serve made for their age. Adult protein powders aren't designed for toddlers. Ours, Kids Immune Protein, is suitable from 12 months.

Nicola x

Disclaimer: This post is for general information only and isn't a substitute for individual medical advice. If you have concerns about your child's growth, eating or health, please talk to your GP or a qualified health professional.

Make their usual milk count

Kids Immune Protein: 9g gentle collagen protein, zinc, vitamin C, vitamin D and gut support in every scoop. From 12 months, no added sugar.

Shop Kids Immune Protein